The incumbent is a buffoon and cricket in Pakistan is a basket case. – Malcolm Speed
It is no secret that the current PCB administration, led by the elderly Ijaz Butt – has broken all records of incompetence. In fact, it wouldn’t be a stretch to claim that the ineptitude shown by the PCB – during Ijaz Butt’s tenure as chairman is the worst in the history of this beleaguered institution. There are no justifications for the inept leadership of a lackey like Ijaz Butt, which has resulted in numerous gaffes. Pakistan cricket has yet to come out of the crisis that fell in after the disastrous 2003 World Cup campaign of an ageing team. It seems that successive ham-fisted PCB regimes after that, have only hastened dis-connect between the cricket loving masses and players.
For all his failures as a cricket administrator, nobody can deny that there have been a few positive developments during his tenure as PCB chairman. However, the negatives have so far, out-weighed the positive aspects of his decision making and management skills. This is just an attempt to highlight the good occurrences – far and few they might have been, under the embattled PCB supreme.
Let us first analyze the record in all 3 formats of the game since Ijaz Butt took over as PCB Chairman.
Tests – 5 Wins | 11 Lost | 7 Draws ——— ODIs – 30 Wins | 31 Lost | 1 No-Result ——— T20s – 18 Wins | 16 Lost
A rocket scientist you need not be, to figure out that when a team in winning consistently, the pressure on the players, coaches and administration is almost non-existent. The perfect example of this was seen at the WC earlier this year, when the ultimate cardinal sin of a devil heading the PCB was forgotten for almost 2 and a half months just because Pakistan made it to the semi-finals.
Now we turn to the positives that have taken place under Ijaz Butt’s tutelage.
2009 T20 World Cup
By a long shot, the greatest moment in the history of Pakistani cricket (and in Ijaz Butt’s life), since the 1992 WC win. The rag-tag group of players, who were almost knocked out of the group stages in the tournament, then went on to win the World Cup in style. Notorious slow starters we are in world events. The team was also helped by the news that Chief Selector, Abdul Qadir had quit due to a row with The Chairman.
Drawing a Test Series against Australia in England
For me the second greatest achievement under The Chairman was the fact that we drew against the, still mighty Australians – with a squad full of youngsters, despite the retirement of another young person just a Test ago. The suave & debonair Salman Butt, led us to a test win against Australia only after a gazillion years. Oh, and a certain pace duo also played a small part in this victory.
Emergence & re-emergence of talent
Umer Akmal, Azhar Ali, Junaid Khan, Asad Shafiq, Umer Amin, Adnan Akmal.
Mohammad Hafeez, Taufeeq Umer, Wahab Riaz.
I left out The Great Left-Arm Hope deliberately.
Drawn series against SA and Away series win against NZ
Re-calling Misbah and making him the test captain out of wilderness was perhaps as shrewd a move as any. Not only did, the Tokay Waali Sarkar from Mianwali led us to a satisfying drawn test series, against the mighty South Africans, but we also came close to winning a test against them, led by the return of the prodigal Younis Khan. An away test series win later on against New Zealand was the first one after a long hiatus of almost 4 years for Team Green.
Close, but no cigar
Near misses include, reaching the 2009 Champions Trophy semi-final, reaching the 2010 T20 WC semi-final and playing in the Mother of All Matches against India in the 2011 WC semi-final. Add, two 3-2 ODI series losses against the England & South Africa. Mid-level triumphs include 3 consecutive ODI series wins against NZ, Windies & Ireland. Butt saab will be desperate to whitewash Zimbabwe as well.
A proper plan for Domestic Cricket
The partnership with Faysal Bank & Geo Super seems to have inducted a new life into the moribund tournament that was the National T20 Championship. Not only has the current PCB regime changed the T20 format by conducting two T20 tournaments per year, but they have also successfully managed to revive public interest in the game. Small wonder then, that the last 3 T20 Championships have attracted large crowds and strong TV audiences.
Another feather in the cap of the current regime was the decision to play the final of the First-Class tournament under lights with the orange ball. It was big surprise that such innovative idea was passed by the governing board headed by Mr. Butt. Introducing & implementing a strict code of conduct Notorious for their off the field activities, Pakistani cricketers find themselves unable to express their feelings to media of all sorts. Bit too late perhaps.
Last but not the least
…and certainly the greatest, is Butt saabs ability to hang in there. Weathering storms and brushing away ridicule comes easy to Butt it seems. Whether it is the terrorist attack on the Srilankan team, the Australian tour fiasco, the oath-gate against Younis Khan, the spot-fixing saga or the screaming accusations against the England cricketers, former and current PCB officials or the country’s senators or MNA’s – Ijaz Butt has shown an uncanny ability to be an immovable object. Little help comes in the form of El Presidente and the Defense Minister, Ahmed Mukhtar.
A friend summed it up perfectly, ‘I think it’s the little things that were allowed to fester that ultimately led to all the bigger issues. Had there been a stronger Chairman who took it on himself to take care of these things by putting the right people in the right places then I’m sure many of these things would not have been allowed to happen. His ineptitude was also apparent at ICC meetings where we were continuously taken the piss out of. He just does not have the skills for the role.’
Perhaps the bolded part above, explains why he is still on the job in our country.